2020 Event Videos
Mar 2020 Newsletter
2019 Fall Meeting
2019 Updated Rules
Coil Operation (or, the bucket analogy)
by Tom Carnegie
All analogies are flawed. If they were perfect, they would be
the thing they were trying to represent. Analogies do serve a
purpose though. They can be a handy teaching device if you
don't get too carried away. Representing electricity with a
hydraulic analogy has been done for years and with some
success. As I mentioned before, of course there are flaws,
but some things translate well. In this analogy, the coil will
be a bucket. A bucket that holds electrons.
In a normal ignition system, the bucket is filled at leisure,
and at the correct moment, something triggers it to dump (the
points of a distributor, for instance).
In a T system, the bucket dumps when it is filled to a certain
level. The need is anticipated and the filling operation
begins in the hope that it will complete at the correct
moment. It supposes that if all four coil's sensing devices are
set to dump at the same level, then it will take the same
amount of time to fill them. This is roughly true.
Unfortunately, for the Montana 500, we don't want anything
to be rough. The main reason that the coils dump at different
times, assuming that they are adjusted the same, is coil
vagaries. In actual fact, as "electron buckets" all coils leak.
It stands to reason that if coils leak they probably leak at
different rates. Also the buckets may be shaped differently
(different wire size, or more turns of wire, for instance).
Some buckets may have wide tops that are easy to fill. Some
may have narrow tops that make filling more difficult. The
question then becomes, "how to minimize the variations?"
First and foremost is to fill the coil with the biggest hose that
you can. The magneto is usually the biggest hose.
Furthermore, it is accurately timed. It gives huge blasts of
electrons at precisely timed intervals. Even furthermore, it
gives bigger blasts the faster the motor goes. As a practical
matter, even though more is better, in regard to magneto
voltage, good enough is usually good enough. What is more
of a problem, but a problem that can be ameliorated
somewhat, is mismatched coils. The definition of matched
coils are "coils that ramp up at the same rate, given the same
voltage". In other words, coils with the same magnetic and
electrical characteristics In other words, buckets shaped alike
that leak at the same rate.
I spent a good deal of time trying to figure out a way to find
four coils with similar properties. I discovered that if you
supply a coil with a controlled pulse of electricity, and record
the oscilloscope trace, each coil has a unique pattern that is
repeatable, to a large degree. A coil "fingerprint" so to speak.
I won't go into the details of exactly how I did this operation,
but I believe it was successful. There is little use to describe
it as most folks don't have an oscilloscope, plus, I'm going to
tell you an easier and better way to get four matching coils.
Buy four new coils.
(end of article)